Tuesday, March 11, 2008

Comma,tation, Nation,

I guess I need to take more time to edit my own blogs because apparently I haven’t been using proper “commatation.” According to my ever vigilant wife, I have failed to include many necessary commas in my writing. She is both right and wrong. Naturally, commas are crucial to writing, but not every pause deserves punctuation. However, in most cases using a comma is correct.

For example, this sentence is correct: Therefore, this matter must be dealt with as quickly as possible.

This sentence is also correct: The board therefore voted unanimously in favor of the acquisition.

The difference is that in the second sentence, the word “therefore” doesn’t interrupt the thought. But it would be conceivable for someone to want to put a comma there because a short natural pause does occur. Commas are by far the most confusing form of punctuation, so out of defiance I limit my use of them.

I use the opposite theory when it comes to wine. Everyday there’s a new rule about how much vino is good for you. Some experts say a glass a day provides great antioxidants to your body, other say that two glasses a day in fine. So out of defiance, I drink a bottle at a time. Take that scientists! I’m chalk full of antioxidants whether it’s good or bad.

The bottom line is that in most cases a comma should be used with a pause. In fact, you can argue that I should have used a comma in that last sentence, but again, I chose not to because I didn’t think the phrase “in most cases” interrupted my thought. Screw this. Now I’m confused. And to think, I recently thought about going into teaching English.

6 comments:

Amber Strahl said...

Ughh, grammar. Just as I was beginning to write this I had to check that I was spelling grammar correctly. Nope, I wasn't. (grammer) So... I guess the next may be easy to surmise, I am not so good at the commas. I think I tend to overuse. I also get a little confused about paragraphs. I mean, it should be relatively easy to figure out, start a new thought/subject, new parargraph, but I just tend to like to talk on. You know, sometimes you just got to get it out, and you, or one I should probably say, one does not have the time to break up the thoughts for the sake of grammar. I mean, maybe I just happen to have extra long thoughts, you know? Maybe I don't need these paragraphs like everyone else does. Really when you-I mean-one thinks about it who really cares about stupid paragraphs. Does one read along and think, wow, I really think the author should have took a breath here and maybe add a paragraph or two... doubtful, very, very, very doubtful.

Malinda and Family said...

You forgot a few commas but I must say... much better. ;)

Burtopia said...

Sorry Amber, I quit reading your comment half way through becuase your thoughts were too conjumbled together. Maybe if they were broken up into paragraphs it would have been easier for me to stay focused. :)

Eric Strahl said...

That's the rub, turkey.

Almost Wifey said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Almost Wifey said...

Hello my name is Emily and I am a comma,holic.

I was even told by a prof at SOU that "one should try not to use commas whenever possible" but I just flipped him the literary bird and kept on inappropriately punctuating.

Also, wine by the bottle is the best way to have it.